Finding Your Confidence as a Gender-Affirming Therapist in Group Supervision
By Jessica Carpenter
Our current socio-political climate is increasingly threatening marginalized folks.
Especially impacted are people of the global majority (PoGM). These are people who are undocumented, individuals impacted by restrictions on bodily autonomy and reproductive rights, and transgender and gender-expansive (TGE) individuals. For many, this experience isn’t new, but with the intensity and frequency of these threats accumulating, as gender-affirming therapists, we need to be informed and equipped to best serve these populations.
With as quickly as policy is changing, ‘know thine jurisdictions’ it is more critical than ever. As professionals, your responsibility is to understand the law, the ethics, and the standards of practice. When it comes to gender-affirming care, therapists may be forced to grapple with incongruences in these areas.

Gender-Affirming Care and the Law: What Therapists Need to Know
Colorado is currently considered one of the more protective states for TGE individuals seeking gender-affirming mental health care. Colorado law recognizes gender-affirming care as protected healthcare. This means that the law prohibits insurers from denying medically necessary care and explicitly includes behavioral and mental health services related to gender dysphoria.
Providers, including therapists, are required to practice within their competency and should be knowledgeable about gender diverse identities and expressions, as well as the assessment and treatment of Gender Dysphoria. As of a recent ruling, laws against conversion therapy in Colorado are in legal flux. However, major professional organizations (covered below) still consider conversion therapy harmful and outside accepted standards of care.
It is critical to note that Colorado anti-discrimination laws protect gender identity. Generally, therapists may not deny services solely because someone is TGE, engage in discriminatory treatment practices, or create a hostile clinical environment.
The Growing Impact of Anti-Trans Legislation on Therapists and Clients
The rise in anti-trans bills in the US is surging, with significant impacts on bathrooms, sports, healthcare, education, and more. Executive orders are trying to limit legal documentation to only reflect the gender binary. Further, they are banning TGE folks from serving in the military which is impacting pensions and healthcare, and they are restricting gender-affirming care for trans youth under 19.
The Supreme Court has allowed states to restrict access to evidence-based gender-affirming medical care for youth and has been cited to uphold adult bans by the 4th circuit court. And as mentioned above, the court ruled that the CO law banning conversion therapy violates the first amendment and that state legislation cannot ban it.
The most oppressive laws currently exist in TX, FL, and KS followed by ID, WY, UT, ND, SD, IA, OK, AR, LA, MS, AL, TN, IN, OH, and WV. In TX specifically, mental health providers (MHPs) offering gender-affirming care for minors could potentially face professional or legal consequences (litigation is ongoing). While gender-affirming psychotherapy is not explicitly banned in many states, laws are written broadly enough that clinicians may fear liability for facilitating care.
Ethics and Standards of Practice for Gender-Affirming Therapists
While there is less explicit content regarding the mental health treatment of TGE folks in most ethical guidelines, almost every major professional medical organization has released statement papers meant to inform standards of care. They are often congruent and emphasize that gender-affirming care (social and medical) is suicide prevention. In states that passed anti-trans laws, suicide attempt rates rose up to 72% among trans and enby youth ages 13-17.
The World Professional Association for Trangender Health sets standards of care and their core philosophy centers around depathologization. They emphasize that gender diversity is a natural variation of the human experience and not a mental disorder. The higher rates of mental health challenges in this population are largely attributed to minority stress rather than the gender identity itself.
They express that psychotherapy should not be a mandatory requirement for starting gender-affirming medical treatments as it should not be used as a barrier to care. MHPs are encouraged to help individuals explore their identity without imposing the provider’s own narratives or preconceptions. The focus of treatment should be on reducing the distress associated with gender dysphoria and minority stress with affirming, person-centered interventions.
The American Psychological Association adopted a policy affirming evidence-based care for TGE children, adolescents, and adults. Key goals of the policy are to combat misinformation, reduce stigma and marginalization, and to integrate scientific research. The ACA practice brief further emphasizes the need for intersex awareness and the use of affirming language. They also highlight the levislative inequity including housing and employment discrimination for TGE folks and note that for youth, bullying is linked to higher rates of depression and attempted suicide.
MHPs are encouraged to use affirming paperwork that uses inclusive language, gender options, and domestic partnership statuses. MHPs should pair intersectional frameworks that include how TGE identities intersect with race, class, and disability with trauma informed care models. They also encourage an emphasis on empowerment, encouraging MHPs to help clients build social support networks to counter the isolation caused by societal oppression.
The American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors, and Therapists (AASECT) views gender-affirming care as a fundamental human right and health imperative. Human Rights factors include:
- Freedom from violence and discrimination (safety)
- Access to agency and bodily autonomy (self-determination, consent, privacy)
- Access to information and education, access to affirming mental/medical healthcare
- Freedom to engage in partnerships and family life
- Absence of disease/dysfunction and access to sexual pleasure
All of which are being challenged across the country at this time.
AASECT explicitly labels conversion/reparative therapy as unethical. They encourage the importance of “gender euphoria” which is the joy and authenticity TGE folks feel when their identity is affirmed. Their statement cites extensive research showing that affirming environments lead to optimal health outcomes, whereas disaffirming policies are documented to cause significant harm, including increased rates of depression and suicide.
How Group Supervision Supports Gender-Affirming Therapists
Group supervision can be an ideal space to process concerns regarding discrepancies between our ethical obligations, expectations for standards of practice, and how these intersect with the law in our respective states. While it may not be an issue in your state yet, major mental health organizations currently view gender-affirming care as evidence-based and consistent with accepted standards of practice.
If you’re faced with the choice of balancing client welfare, legal compliance, and professional ethics, it’s important to remember that supervision and consultation are spaces where courses of action, deliberation of risks and benefits, and selection of objective decisions are weighed for the welfare of all involved. This process is expected of us and along with compliance of widely accepted professional standards, supervision and consultation, careful documentation, and knowledge of our state-specific laws, we can hope to continue providing gender-affirming care in a manner compliant with the standards of our profession. If you are experiencing anxiety, guilt, or fear, it may be beneficial to seek additional individual support.
Using Group Supervision to Build Gender-Affirming Clinical Skills
Group supervision can also be a supportive space to practice some of the skills we use to provide gender-affirming care. Share your own pronouns and ask what name/pronouns would feel best for group members to use when making introductions. If misgendering occurs, own your actions gracefully in as few words as possible.
Pause, correct the mistake, and finish your thought (whether the misgendered person is present or not). Have ongoing discussions about evidence-based practices that prevent harm, prioritize client safety, and uphold our ethical obligations and professional competence. If other group members espouse personal ideology or try to dictate treatment that goes against professional or ethical codes, practice “calling them in” and share some of what you’re learning regarding what is in the best interest of TGE clients.
If TGE folks are part of your group, it is critical to protect against shifting the burden on them. They may need space to care for themselves outside of the group if oppressive practices are being discussed.
How We Can Help
The landscape for gender-affirming care is shifting rapidly and no therapist should be navigating it alone. Group supervision offers a space to process the ethical tensions, sharpen your clinical skills, and stay grounded in evidence-based practice alongside peers who share your commitment to this work. At Firelight Supervision, our supervision groups are built for exactly these conversations. Reach out today to learn more about our current groups and find the right fit for where you are in your practice.
Author Bio
Jessica Carpenter is a licensed professional counselor, couples counselor, and blogger with Catalyss Counseling and Firelight Supervision. Jessica helps adults build and sustain stronger relationships with themselves and others, with a focus on anxiety, grief, trauma, and relationship challenges including communication, conflict, and affair recovery. She specializes in working with the LGBTQIA+ community and polyamorous and non-monogamous relationships, bringing a somatic, integrative approach rooted in IFS, Gottman Method, and a decade of experience in bodywork. Follow Firelight Supervision on Instagram, Facebook, and LinkedIn.





Leave a Comment